After the gut punch of Arondir’s death, I expected The Rings of Power season 3 episode 5, “The Lady of Lórien,” to hit the ground running. It doesn’t. The episode follows Galadriel (Morfydd Clark) and Celeborn (Jamie Campbell Bower) through the Greenwood, Elrond (Robert Aramayo) sailing to Númenor, and Gandalf (Daniel Weyman) facing Pallando in Rhûn, while Sauron (Charlie Vickers) tightens his grip on everyone.
There are a few strong scenes, but I walked away feeling like I’d watched a lot of setup and very little story. Here’s the full rundown, with my honest reactions along the way. Spoilers ahead.
Quick facts
- Aired: November 18, 2026, on Prime Video
- Written by: J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay
- Directed by: Sanaa Hamri
- What’s next: episode 6, “From Valinor,” is already out, and the finale lands November 25 (no spoilers for those here)
Sauron Breaks Marnûkh and Lets Him Live
The episode opens with Sauron torturing Marnûkh to find out where Galadriel went. It doesn’t take long. Once Sauron threatens the Orc’s five children, Marnûkh talks, and he reveals that Galadriel and Celeborn are heading south toward the Greenwood.
Then comes the cruelest part. Marnûkh’s children are already dead. Sauron refuses to kill him, promising he’ll live long enough to see the One Ring completed. I found that more chilling than any death would have been, because it shows how Sauron punishes people: not with a quick end, but by leaving them alive to carry it. It also confirms that Marnûkh survived the chaos at Gundabad.
With the information in hand, Sauron sends his Orc legions after Galadriel.
Theo Skips the Grief and Asks About His Mother
Sauron then dismisses Theo, who’s still struggling with his new allegiance. You’d think he’d be wrestling with having killed Arondir. Instead, he wants to know whether Sauron can help him speak to his dead mother.
I’ll be honest: this is the scene that bothered me most, and not in a good way. It could have been a powerful moment, with Theo showing guilt or confusion. But Arondir’s death doesn’t register at all, and I’ll come back to that in a minute.
Elros Chooses Mortality, and Elrond Sees a Death Sentence
The episode then jumps back thousands of years to the First Age, where Elrond meets his twin brother, Elros (also played by Aramayo). Elros tells him he’s given up immortality to become Númenor’s first king. Elrond sees that as a death sentence and doesn’t think the Men of Númenor deserve such a sacrifice. Elros disagrees. He believes they could become a shining light of hope for Middle-earth.
It’s a thoughtful flashback, and it gives Elrond’s current mission a personal weight. Back in the present, Elrond thinks it over as he sails toward Númenor with Gil-galad (Benjamin Walker) and the other Elves.
Elrond Sails to Númenor, and Pharazôn Names His Price
When they arrive, they meet Pharazôn, who agrees to consider an alliance against Sauron. There’s a catch, of course. He wants Gil-galad and Elrond to persuade Míriel and the Faithful to surrender.
Gil-galad is willing to think about it. Elrond isn’t. He believes it would betray everything his brother stood for. Instead, he finds Isildur, who takes him to Míriel, and she assumes Elrond has come to lead the Faithful into battle against Pharazôn. That couldn’t be further from the truth, and the awkwardness of that misunderstanding was one of the few moments of dry humor in the episode.
I liked that Númenor finally gets its due here. A reviewer elsewhere noted that Belzagar is fascinated by Elrond’s resemblance to Elros, which hints at how far the kingdom has drifted from its founding ideals. It’s a small thing, but it gave the Númenor scenes a little extra flavor.
Celeborn’s Story: Ancalagon, a Prison, and a Missed Call at Thangorodrim
Meanwhile, Galadriel and Celeborn press deeper into the forest, though they’re still fifty leagues from the Woodland Elves. When they finally catch their breath, Celeborn tells her what happened to him all those centuries ago. During the War of Wrath, his legion was attacked by the dragon Ancalagon, and just before the flames took them, his horse kicked him into a ditch full of water. That’s what saved him.
He survived but was captured by the Orcs and spent centuries in their dungeons. He even befriended an Orc named Hazgarak by telling stories about Galadriel, though they fell out over a lock of her hair. Celeborn also says he saw Galadriel during the fall of Thangorodrim and called out to her. She thought he was another vision and kept searching for Sauron instead.
This was the heart of the episode for me. Bower gives Celeborn a gentle, battered warmth, and Clark sells Galadriel’s guilt without overdoing it. Celeborn never gave up hope that Galadriel was alive, and he even dreamed that she’d someday become the Lady of Lórien. That detail is the one thing that made the title feel earned.
A Nightmare in the Trees and Sauron’s Trap
Eventually, the two find shelter in a tree and become intimate. But Galadriel then has another disturbing nightmare, imagining Sauron lying beside her instead of Celeborn. Startled, she falls from the tree and knocks herself unconscious, which draws nearby Orcs.
Celeborn tries to protect her by telling the Orcs he’s traveling alone. Then Sauron arrives on his Fell Beast. According to Reactor, he was riding Ancalagon at the time of Celeborn’s story, which gives the scene an unsettling echo. Neither he nor his Orcs seem to search the immediate area, and I can’t stop thinking about how convenient that is. A woman is lying unconscious near the spot where they found Celeborn, and no one checks. It’s a plot contrivance that gets harder to ignore the longer I think about it.
Instead, Sauron takes Celeborn prisoner, confident Galadriel will come looking and fall back into his grasp. When Galadriel wakes, she can only watch as the Fell Beast disappears into the distance.
Gandalf Fights Pallando, and Refuses to Fight Back
In Rhûn, Gandalf tries to convince Pallando to give up Sauron and join him. Pallando refuses, revealing he’s received a prophecy that he’ll die at the hands of a Ring-bearer, while Gandalf will die at Sauron’s hands. The two come to blows, but Gandalf won’t fight back, still believing his fellow Wizard can be saved. Khamûl eventually steps in and orders Pallando to stop, explaining that Sauron wants Gandalf alive.
The episode ends with Gandalf chained to the back of an oliphaunt and carried toward Mordor.
I like that Gandalf stays true to his mission and doesn’t strike back. Even so, this storyline feels like it’s treading water. The fight also reminded me of the Gandalf and Saruman duel in The Fellowship of the Ring, which only adds to the feeling that the show can’t stop borrowing from Peter Jackson’s films.
Why Arondir’s Death Still Doesn’t Matter
Let me say what’s been nagging at me. Arondir’s death has no ramifications for anyone. Not for Theo, who’s chasing his mother’s memory, and not even for Galadriel, who doesn’t mention it once or dwell on it anywhere in the episode. As I said last week, that only reinforces how little we should care about these characters, because the people in the story don’t seem to care either.
It’s also hard to ignore how much else gets left behind. The Harfoots aren’t mentioned at all anymore, which feels like a quiet admission that their story didn’t work in the first two seasons. And the biggest sin of the hour is simple: it’s boring. There isn’t enough happening to justify nearly an hour, and three seasons in, this show still doesn’t have an identity of its own. Even the “it is a gift” scene from Jackson’s trilogy gets echoed here, which stings more when the rest of the hour feels so empty.
What Worked and What Didn’t
What worked
- Celeborn’s backstory. The Ancalagon story and his years in captivity give his character real depth, and Bower sells it.
- Sauron’s cruelty to Marnûkh. Leaving the Orc alive after revealing his children are dead is quietly brutal.
- Elrond and Elros. The flashback adds personal stakes to the alliance mission.
- Gandalf’s refusal to fight back. It fits his mission to save Pallando.
What didn’t
- Arondir’s missing aftermath. No one grieves him, including Galadriel, which weakens the death and the characters.
- The Orc search. Nobody checks the area where Galadriel fell.
- Borrowed scenes. The Gandalf fight and the “gift” moment echo Jackson’s films.
- Pacing. There’s too little story for the run-time, and Gandalf’s Rhûn plot barely moves.
- Forgotten threads. The Harfoots have vanished from the story.
My Score: 5.5 / 10
“The Lady of Lórien” has a few strong moments, especially Celeborn’s backstory and Sauron’s cruelty toward Marnûkh. But the episode barely moves, leans on borrowed scenes, and ignores the emotional fallout from Arondir’s death. After a shaky run of episodes, this is the weakest of the five for me. I’m not giving up on the season, but I need the finale stretch to give me a reason to care.
FAQ
How did Celeborn survive Ancalagon in The Rings of Power? During the War of Wrath, his legion was attacked by the dragon Ancalagon. Just before the flames reached them, his horse kicked him into a ditch filled with water. He survived and was later captured by Orcs.
What prophecy does Pallando mention? He says he’s received a prophecy that he’ll die at the hands of a Ring-bearer, while Gandalf will die at Sauron’s hands.
Does Marnûkh survive episode 5? Yes. Sauron tortures him for information about Galadriel and Celeborn, then keeps him alive, promising he’ll live to see the One Ring completed.