The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 3 “The Secret Fire” Recap & Review: Gandalf’s Mission, Khamûl’s Betrayal, and a Trap Elendil Never Sees Coming

Sari 9 min read 1 views 0 comments
The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 3 "The Secret Fire" Recap & Review: Gandalf's Mission, Khamûl's Betrayal, and a Trap Elendil Never Sees Coming

Three episodes in, The Rings of Power finally gives Gandalf something real to do. “The Secret Fire,” season 3 episode 3, sends Gandalf (Daniel Weyman) and Tom Bombadil (Rory Kinnear) to Rhûn, where Khamûl turns on the Dark Wizard and Gandalf learns the truth about his own mission. Elsewhere, Elendil walks into a trap, Galadriel and Arondir follow Marnûkh toward Gundabad, and Sauron does something truly nasty to a pair of Elven prisoners. I’ll go through all of it and tell you where I felt the episode worked and where it kept reminding me of other stories. Spoilers ahead, so you’ve been warned.

Quick facts

  • Aired: November 11, 2026, on Prime Video, as part of the four-episode premiere drop
  • Written by: J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay
  • Directed by: Sanaa Hamri
  • Listed runtime: 58 minutes
  • What’s next: episode 4 is titled “Gundabad”

Khamûl Turns on the Dark Wizard in Rhûn

Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 3 opens in Rhûn, where the Dark Wizard is getting ready to welcome representatives of the Gaudrim back to his court. Gandalf and Tom Bombadil are watching from the sidelines, hoping to learn what Sauron has planned. Then Khamûl strides in wearing his new Ring of Power and announces that he no longer serves the Wizard, because his loyalty now belongs to Sauron.

The Dark Wizard tries to hit him with magic, but the Ring shields Khamûl from it. Khamûl then challenges the Wizard’s authority and threatens to expose what happened to his former partner. He urges the people of Rhûn to abandon their master. They do, naturally. I loved watching the Wizard lose his grip in real time, because it turns a man who looked untouchable in the premiere into someone suddenly powerless as his followers walk away.

It also shows how Sauron’s Rings work in practice. A Ring doesn’t just make you stronger, it hands you the confidence to tear down the person who used to be above you. With the army preparing to march on Mordor, Gandalf realizes something has to happen before it’s too late.

Gandalf Meets the Secret Fire and Learns He’s Meant to Save Pallando

Gandalf’s staff is getting more powerful, and after he frees an oliphaunt from its aggression, he starts to suspect that defeating the Dark Wizard could stop Rhûn’s armies from joining Sauron. Tom, meanwhile, keeps speaking in riddles and singing songs, which drives Gandalf up the wall. I couldn’t blame him.

The big moment comes when Gandalf heads outside to find food. While chasing a rabbit, he starts singing one of Tom’s songs, and the animal bursts into flames. The sky darkens, and Gandalf finds himself facing a divine presence called the Secret Fire. It explains that five servants were sent to Middle-earth to protect its people from evil. They’re the Istari, and Gandalf is one of them. Another is the Dark Wizard, whose real name is Pallando.

Pallando was one of two Wizards sent to protect Rhûn, but his hunger for power led him to murder his companion. The betrayal was so terrible that it turned the surrounding lands into the barren desert we see today. Here’s the twist that I found most interesting: Gandalf hasn’t been sent to destroy Pallando. He’s meant to save the fallen Wizard and bring him back to the light. Only by working together can they stop Rhûn’s armies from joining Sauron.

I’ll be honest about my reaction. The idea itself is good, and it fits Gandalf better than a straight fight would. But the scene is a big lore dump delivered by a glowing presence, and it felt more like a character handing out homework than a story unfolding on its own.

Tom Bombadil Vanishes and Leaves a Hat Behind

With his mission finally clear, Gandalf hurries back to Tom’s home, only to find that the mysterious fellow has disappeared. The only thing left behind is Gandalf’s iconic grey hat. It’s a sweet, strange little exit, and I’ll admit I smiled.

Elendil Walks Into Kemen’s Trap

Over in western Númenor, the Faithful are led by Anárion, who helps train the soldiers and reminds them to stay alert against the king’s forces. Elendil then pulls his son aside and reveals there’s a spy in their ranks, someone preparing to meet Pharazôn’s men at the ruins of an old stargazing tower.

We know this is a trap, of course, because we watched Pharazôn build it. Elendil doesn’t. When he arrives, Kemen and his soldiers burst out of hiding and surround him. Kemen then cruelly taunts him about his daughter’s death, which is how Elendil learns what happened to Eärien. Anárion fires arrows and kills several attackers, but it’s too late, and Kemen’s men drag Elendil away. The Faithful have just lost one of their most important leaders.

The scene is brutal, and the news about Eärien lands hard. Still, I couldn’t shake how easily Elendil strolled into this. After being warned about a spy, he doesn’t seem to wonder whether the information itself might be bait. It’s a stumble in an otherwise strong setup.

Marnûkh’s Road Trip: Galadriel, Arondir, and a Very Gollum-Like Guide

Galadriel and Arondir keep following Marnûkh toward Gundabad. Along the way, he happily talks about his people’s eating habits and enjoys provoking Arondir, especially when the subject is Bronwyn’s death. That’s cruel, and it works, because the Orc clearly knows exactly where to poke.

Marnûkh steers the group away from the Coldfells, warning that his former legion is about to launch a major assault there. It’s a convenient detour, particularly with two Nazgnagôl chasing them, and eventually the trio has to take cover as the Ring-servants close in. Galadriel distracts the pursuers with a swarm of butterflies, and the three stay hidden.

Here’s where the familiarity started to bug me. The hiding scene looks almost identical to Frodo and the Hobbits ducking the Nazgûl in The Fellowship of the Ring. And the dynamic between Marnûkh, Galadriel, and Arondir keeps borrowing from Gollum, Frodo, and Sam in The Two Towers and The Return of the King. Three seasons in, the writers still lean on Tolkien’s best-known moments instead of building something that stands on its own.

Arondir grows more suspicious. He thinks the Orc may be steering them into a trap and urges Galadriel to rethink the mission. She holds firm, convinced that saving the surviving Elven smith is their best chance of stopping Sauron. She also sees that Arondir is still struggling with grief and encourages him to leave and find Theo while she continues toward Gundabad.

Sauron’s Cruelest Interrogation Yet: Carammir, Ellas, and the Fire-Drake Poison

Back in Mordor, Sauron learns that Marnûkh is heading north with the Elves. After looking into the Orc’s past, he discovers that Marnûkh was a skilled torturer who served at Eregion during its destruction. That’s a heck of a detail to drop about a character the show seems to want us to half-trust.

Sauron then brings in two Elven prisoners, Carammir and Ellas, who’ve been held in the labor pits since Eregion fell. They’re married. He poisons Ellas with something derived from a fire-drake and threatens to let her die unless Carammir tells him what he wants to know. Desperate, Carammir reveals that a surviving Elven smith may still be alive.

That finally gives Sauron what he needs. He hands over the antidote, but Ellas dies before her husband can give it to her. I won’t pretend that scene was easy to watch. It’s cold and cruel, and it’s exactly the kind of moment that reminds you who Sauron is when he doesn’t have an audience he needs to charm.

With Gundabad in his sights, Sauron orders his men to prepare his flying beast so he can reach the fortress before Galadriel. Along the way, the Dark Lord also crowns another Ring-servant whose identity stays hidden beneath a helmet. The episode doesn’t say who it is, and I’ll leave the guessing to the comment section.

The Attack That Proves Marnûkh Right

As the episode closes, Arondir is ready to abandon the mission and go look for Theo. Then he spots Sauron’s forces launching their attack in the distance, right where Marnûkh said they’d be. Realizing the Orc told the truth, Arondir changes his mind and rejoins Galadriel and Marnûkh as they approach Gundabad, where the rescue mission is about to begin.

What Worked and What Didn’t

What worked

  • Khamûl vs. the Dark Wizard. A great scene that shows the Rings’ power and strips the Wizard of his authority.
  • Gandalf’s purpose. Saving Pallando instead of destroying him suits Gandalf’s character.
  • Sauron’s interrogation. Cruel, tense, and effective, though hard to watch.
  • Tom’s exit. A warm, strange farewell with a nice hat payoff.

What didn’t

  • Borrowed scenes. The Nazgnagôl hiding sequence mirrors The Fellowship of the Ring almost beat for beat.
  • Gollum-style dynamics. Marnûkh, Galadriel, and Arondir keep echoing Gollum, Frodo, and Sam.
  • Elendil’s trap. He walks into it too easily after being warned of a spy.
  • Writing and characters. The dialogue and character development remain underwhelming, and there are few characters I truly want to root for. The blurred line between right and wrong feels closer to Game of Thrones than to Tolkien’s traditional ideas about courage and corrupting power.

My Score: 6 / 10

“The Secret Fire” has a handful of strong scenes, especially Khamûl’s takeover in Rhûn and the grim interrogation in Mordor. Gandalf’s mission also finally gives him a clear direction. But the episode leans too hard on familiar imagery and recycled dynamics, and the Elendil trap felt too easy. Moral complexity can work, but it needs sharper writing and characters to make it land, and I’m still waiting on both.

FAQ

Who is the Dark Wizard in The Rings of Power season 3? The Secret Fire reveals his real name is Pallando. He was one of two Wizards sent to protect Rhûn, until his desire for power led him to murder his companion.

What is the Secret Fire? It’s a divine presence that appears to Gandalf after the rabbit scene. It explains that five servants were sent to Middle-earth, and it tells Gandalf his mission is to save Pallando, not destroy him.

Who directed “The Secret Fire”? Sanaa Hamri directed it, from a script by J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay. It aired November 11, 2026, on Prime Video.

Rings of Power S3 Episode 2 | Rings of Power S3 Episode 4

Leave a comment