The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 4 “Gundabad” Recap & Review: Arondir’s Death, Celeborn’s Return, and a Rescue Mission With Nothing Left to Rescue

Sari 10 min read 2 views 0 comments
The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 4 "Gundabad" Recap & Review: Arondir's Death, Celeborn's Return, and a Rescue Mission With Nothing Left to Rescue

I went into The Rings of Power season 3 episode 4, “Gundabad,” expecting a tense rescue. What I got was a pointless rescue, a surprise reunion, a Dwarven throne changing hands, and the death of a character who’s been around since the first season. Galadriel (Morfydd Clark), Arondir (Ismael Cruz Córdova), and Marnûkh (Adam Young) sneak into the Orc fortress hoping to save the last Elven smith, Sauron (Charlie Vickers) races to get there first, and Theo (Tyroe Muhafidin) turns up in a way nobody on the Elven side wanted. I’ll walk through the whole episode, scene by scene, and tell you where it landed and where it fell apart. Heavy spoilers ahead.

Quick facts

  • Aired: November 11, 2026, on Prime Video, as the fourth episode of the premiere drop
  • Written by: Justin Doble
  • Directed by: Sanaa Hamri
  • Listed runtime: 57 minutes
  • What’s next: episodes 5 and 6 arrived November 18, and the finale lands November 25 (no spoilers for those here)

Sauron Saddles Up a Fell Beast

The episode opens with Sauron getting ready to travel to Gundabad, determined to arrive before Galadriel and her companions. He flies there on a Fell Beast, a monstrous flying creature that Sauron says was once an Eagle before Morgoth corrupted it. I liked that little detail, because it gives the creature a sad history instead of just making it a scary prop.

Marnûkh’s Prisoner Ruse Gets the Elves Inside Gundabad

Galadriel, Arondir, and Marnûkh arrive at Gundabad with no idea Sauron is already on his way. Marnûkh presents the two Elves as fresh prisoners and convinces the Orc guards he’s bringing new captives for the dungeons. He orders Galadriel locked up until Sauron arrives and says Arondir is headed for torture. Neither Elf looks happy about the arrangement, and honestly, who could blame them? We’ve spent the past few episodes being reminded that Marnûkh used to serve Sauron.

Once they reach the lower levels, though, Marnûkh turns on the guards and helps Arondir overpower them. The two of them start searching the cells for Maitalle, hoping to get the surviving Elven smith out before Sauron arrives.

Maitalle Is Dead, and Celeborn Is Very Much Alive

Here’s the cruel joke at the center of this episode: Maitalle is already dead. She’s apparently been dead for several weeks, which makes the entire mission pointless. While Arondir and Marnûkh are absorbing that, another prisoner overhears them and offers to help them escape. It’s Celeborn.

Galadriel’s long-lost husband has been held at Gundabad for centuries, and he knows the fortress and its passages remarkably well. He promises to help Arondir and Marnûkh get out if they release him. I’ll admit the reveal gave me a small jolt, and Jamie Campbell Bower plays the moment with a calm that I enjoyed.

Then the logic problems start piling up, and I can’t let them go. Across these four episodes, we’ve seen that Sauron’s forces can track Marnûkh across Middle-earth and pass intelligence over huge distances. Yet we’re expected to believe that an entire Orc fortress full of Sauron loyalists never mentioned that they were holding the last Elven smith and Galadriel’s husband? And Marnûkh, who personally delivered Maitalle to Gundabad and served as a master torturer, somehow had no idea she’d died weeks earlier?

Either Sauron’s intelligence network has suddenly become incompetent, or Marnûkh led Galadriel and Arondir into an enemy stronghold based on information he never bothered to check. I don’t find either explanation convincing. What bugs me most is that the whole mission conveniently ends with Galadriel finding her husband instead. It feels like the writers worked backward from the outcome they wanted, and I’ll be blunt: the love triangle seems to have been the goal all along.

Durin vs. Thráin: A Throne Decided by Trial by Combat

Meanwhile, in Khazad-dûm, the political situation keeps getting worse. The Dwarven lords have heard reports that Sauron’s forces are gathering near their borders, and they’re worried. Many believe the Seven Dwarven Rings could give them the power to protect their people, but Durin (Owain Arthur) insists the Rings are too dangerous to use.

Thráin (Eddie Marsan) disagrees and openly challenges his brother’s leadership, arguing that Durin’s refusal puts the whole kingdom at risk. Things escalate until a trial by combat is the only way to settle the succession. Disa (Sophia Nomvete) is worried, especially since Thráin has been trying to manipulate her this whole time. He offers to give up his claim to the throne if Durin hands over the Rings, and he threatens to reveal their past. It turns out Disa and Thráin slept together during an earlier separation between her and Durin.

Disa doesn’t let Thráin turn that secret into a weapon. She tells her husband the truth herself. Durin is hurt, and he eventually forgives her, deciding their relationship matters more than a mistake from the past. I’ll give the show credit for letting that conversation breathe, because it’s one of the more grounded moments in the episode.

It doesn’t solve everything, though. While they prepare for the trial, their son Gamli mentions seeing Disa and Thráin together. Durin misreads the encounter and loses his focus, which lets Thráin beat him in the trial and become the new King of Khazad-dûm. Other recaps also note that Thráin had a chance to kill Durin and chose to knock him out instead. That’s a small detail, but it suggests there’s still something complicated going on inside Thráin.

Here’s my problem: the Dwarven storyline leans on yet another romantic complication to move the plot. It’s the same habit I flagged in the premiere, and it makes the succession fight feel smaller than it should.

Elrond Wants to Sail to Númenor

The Elves, meanwhile, are struggling to hold back Sauron’s growing armies. Lindon’s forces win another battle, but their losses are piling up. Elrond returns from the fighting and urges Gil-galad to reconsider an alliance with Númenor. The catch is that Pharazôn has already turned down their earlier diplomatic attempts.

Elrond thinks a personal appeal from the High King could change that, especially given his own resemblance to his twin brother Elros, Númenor’s legendary founder. He suggests they sail across the sea and make their case in person. It’s a brief scene, but it hints at where the Elven plot might head next.

Isildur and Anárion Free Elendil and Capture Kemen

Elsewhere, Isildur and Anárion are getting ready to rescue Elendil from Kemen’s forces. They ambush the soldiers transporting him, free their father, and capture Kemen in the process. For now, they decide to keep Pharazôn’s son alive, since he could be a valuable bargaining chip in the conflict ahead. I enjoyed seeing the Faithful finally land a win after the trap that cost them so much in the previous episode.

Breaking Out of Gundabad

Back at Gundabad, Arondir and Marnûkh continue their escape with Celeborn. They find Galadriel, who has already freed herself and is fighting her way through the fortress, and the husband and wife are finally reunited. The moment is short-lived, because Sauron arrives at Gundabad.

With the Dark Lord’s forces closing in, the group tries to escape. Marnûkh pretends to betray the Elves again, only to turn on the Orcs and free the prisoners. The chaos lets the group fight their way toward the upper levels, though plenty of guards still stand in their way.

Eventually, Galadriel manages to summon an Eagle named Landroval, which gives them a possible way out. Then another Nazgnagôl appears and blocks the path.

Theo Kills Arondir

Arondir steps forward to face the mysterious figure, and the Nazgnagôl removes the mask. It’s Theo.

The young man has accepted one of Sauron’s Rings and now serves the Dark Lord, and Arondir is horrified after everything he went through trying to protect Theo and Bronwyn. Theo’s first move is to warn Arondir to walk away, telling him Sauron mainly wants Galadriel and Celeborn. Arondir refuses to leave him. He urges Theo to take off the Ring, promising they can still escape together, and for a moment Theo seems to waver.

Then Sauron arrives, and as Galadriel and Celeborn prepare to flee, he orders Theo to kill Arondir. Theo drives his sword through him. Galadriel and Celeborn escape on the Eagle, and Arondir is left behind, mortally wounded.

I’ll be honest about how this scene felt: it was well staged, and Córdova and Muhafidin both gave it weight. But it didn’t hurt the way it clearly wanted to. After three seasons, I never fully connected with Arondir as a character, and a big death only lands when you’ve been made to care.

Why Arondir’s Death Didn’t Break Me

As I’ve said throughout these recaps, The Rings of Power struggles to create characters I’m truly invested in. None of them feel fully developed, and you could argue Sauron is the only one with real depth. So when the show asks me to mourn Arondir, there’s not much to draw on. That’s not a knock on the actors. It’s a writing problem.

And the writing problem goes beyond characterization. In this episode, it ranges from painfully contrived to flat-out nonsensical, which is frustrating because it’s been a pattern across all three seasons. The show sets up rules, then ignores them whenever they get inconvenient. The result feels like the plot is steered by what the writers want to happen, and not by what the story has established.

The series also keeps recycling scenes from Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings trilogy, down to familiar camera framing, character dynamics, and carefully chosen lines of dialogue. With a budget this big, access to one of the richest fantasy worlds ever created, and three seasons to find its own voice, I expected more. Expensive CGI, elaborate costumes, and sweeping shots of Middle-earth can’t make up for weak writing.

What Worked and What Didn’t

What worked

  • Celeborn’s reveal. A surprise that gives Jamie Campbell Bower something fun to play.
  • Disa’s honesty. Telling Durin the truth herself is a mature, grounded moment.
  • The prison break and the Eagle. Big, visual action with a satisfying escape.
  • The Fell Beast detail. A short line of backstory that adds some sadness to a scary creature.

What didn’t

  • The rescue plot. Maitalle’s death weeks earlier makes the mission feel pointless, and the logic around it doesn’t hold up.
  • Intelligence gaps. No one in Gundabad tells Sauron about Maitalle or Celeborn, which clashes with how efficient his network has been.
  • Arondir’s death. It’s shocking, but the show hasn’t built enough connection to make it hurt.
  • Borrowed imagery. Familiar framing and dialogue from Jackson’s trilogy keep creeping in.
  • Writing quality. Convenient twists and ignored story rules.

My Score: 6 / 10

“Gundabad” has real ambition and some strong visuals, plus a few good character beats like Disa’s confession and Celeborn’s entrance. But the logic holes are too big to ignore, and Arondir’s death never earns the emotion it’s reaching for. I give it a 6 out of 10, and if this is the level of storytelling coming for the rest of the season, I’m worried.

FAQ

Who dies in The Rings of Power season 3 episode 4? Arondir is killed when Theo, now a Nazgnagôl under Sauron’s control, stabs him on Sauron’s orders at Gundabad.

Who wins the trial by combat in Khazad-dûm? Thráin defeats Durin and becomes the new King of Khazad-dûm. Durin loses focus after Gamli mentions seeing Disa and Thráin together.

How do Galadriel and Celeborn escape Gundabad? Arondir and Marnûkh free Celeborn from his cell, and Galadriel later summons an Eagle named Landroval. She and Celeborn escape on it while Arondir is left behind.

Rings of Power S3 Episode 3 | Rings of Power S3 Episode 5

Leave a comment